What I learned is probably painfully obvious to someone with more experience with these kinds of projects. If you're thinking of building this platform and don't have a lot of experience with this stuff, maybe you'll find some of the below useful.
I chose this platform without ever having seen it in person. For me, it was critical the platform lessen reverberations (more so than noise) from drops. My garage is on a hill and hence not on solid ground, and the garage flooring is shared with a neighbor's garage. This platform seemed best to lessen reverberations.
The 2x4s called for aren't really 2x4, but measure 1.5"x3.5". I suppose they're just generically called 2x4s. It's confusing, because the store had beams measuring both 2"x4" and 1.5"x3.5". 1.5x3.5 is definitely wanted, otherwise the 5'9" length for the beams doesn't make sense.
On the 5 sheets of plywood called for, you don't really want all five to be a true 3/4" thickness. The top sheet can be, because likely the horse mats are really 3/4" thick (mine are). A nicer grade is good for the top sheet too. I got oak plywood that was a true 3/4" for the top sheet.
For the other 4, a lower grade is fine. There was a 5x cost difference between the top sheet and the lower grade stuff I got. More importantly, I'd recommend a 23/32" thick sheets here, not 3/4". First, it's probably easier to find this thickness in the lower grade stuff. More importantly, the leftover scrap turned into spacers between the 20 1.5x3.5 cross beams in the middle of the platform will fit perfectly.
I did read some Norm Abrams articles on the This Old House site on plywood ratings and all that. It was interesting, but in the end, not terribly important. I picked the bottom 4 sheets by thickness and cost (23/32" and cheap), and the top sheet by looks and thickness (nice and 3/4").
I had Home Depot (where I bought the wood, etc) do all the cuts except the spacers, because I didn't really have a good way to cut big sheets of plywood. Plus, they only charged me $2.00 for all these cuts. (The guy must have been in a good mood, because their sign says the first 2 cuts are free, and every cut after is 25 cents.) The cuts on the plywood are pretty forgiving; however, I wish they'd been a little more exact on the beams. Fortunately, they weren't ever a little too short. But a few things were off just an 1/8" of an inch (or less) here and there. I started touching these up myself, but I wish I'd realized this from the start. A few places in the final platform are just a hair off as a result. It doesn't affect anything, though, other than nag at my anal retentive tendencies.
Also, Home Depot quoted me $80 for delivery. However, they also rent out a truck for $20 for 1.5 hours to those with a license, credit card and proof of insurance. I took the DIY delivery option, and got it done for $20 all in.
Making the double 5'9" beams, the base (what I call the 4'x6' double layering of plywood that makes up the bottom of the platform), and the frame (the 4 sets of double 5'9" beams connected to the two 8' beams) was uneventful and straightforward. I used both glue and screws on the double beams as well as the base.
Attaching the base to the frame isn't really covered in the video. I ended up putting the frame on the ground, then the base on top, and took some care to try and line things up as good as possible. (Here's where I first noticed some of the cuts by Home Depot were slightly off.) I put something like 14 2.5" screws through the base into the frame, evenly spaced, down each of the four 5'9" beams, plus 2 extra screws in each corner. I also put a few along the edge, through the base into the 8' long beams making up the front and back edge. That seems very solid. Flipping the thing back over after this is fun, as by now the beast of a platform is starting to get heavy.
Carpet places in the Bay Area won't just give away scraps or old samples. I was surprised by that. One place let me crawl around in their dumpster and see what I could find. This was unpleasant; some used carpet is plain nasty, and I was concerned about mold and those kinds of issues. I lucked out, and some of the workers pulled up to dump more stuff in the dumpster as I was mucking about in it. They were pretty amused by my little scheme, and helped me out by finding some decent stuff in the lot they were going to dump. I ended up paying nothing for the carpet.
Next, back at home, I decided to use the center well in the platform as a place to cut the carpet. I did buy a new pack of utility blades for $1 -- that's well worth it. Fresh blades makes cutting carpet a snap. This was probably the second biggest time consumption in the project, after drilling and screwing in screws. I cut around 16 pieces of carpet per well that fit nearly exactly in the well.
I cut the spacers at this point. I used a leftover 2'x4' piece of the low grade plywood. I measured parallel lines 2" apart on the wood, and cut 20 2"x2' spacers with a skilsaw. The 2" height on the spacers seemed about right. The skilsaw made this step easy and quick.
For those 20 cross beams in the center of the platform, I started putting them in at each side (by the weight wells), and met in the middle with 2 of the beams touching with no spacer in between. It was just tight enough where I had to hammer in the final spacer, and pressure was perfect to hold things firmly in place while I screwed in all the cross beams using 2 2.5" wood screws at each end of the cross beam. I didn't glue or attach the spacers in any way. I was very happy with how this part turned out. The platform is starting to look finished.
Incidentally, I put in a lot of screws building this thing. It seems this is where the bulk of the time goes on the project. I started the project with this crummy little drill, and would exhaust the rechargeable battery every 10-15 screws I'd drill and screw in with it. After putting up with this for awhile, I finally did a little research and ended up dropping $50 on a new, corded drill that had a keyed chuck. The little drill had a keyless chuck, and the slippage was yet another way this little drill was driving me nuts. (And no, I wouldn't rush the drill, and I did clear the bit several times per hole.) The new drill made a dramatic difference. I would guess I drilled and screwed in over 250 screws. If your drill is not up to the job, then borrow, buy, or rent a decent one. It will make this project go so much faster and easier.
Another thing: a small box of the 1.25" wood screws was sufficient, but one small box of 2.5" wood screws was not. By "small", I mean a 1 lb box. I needed 3 1lb boxes of the 2.5" screws. I literally used every 2.5" screw in those 3 boxes, down to the last one.
I had originally planned on building a simpler 8'x8' platform (just 5 sheets of 4'x8' plywood, no cuts, and the horsemats) before I moved. However, once I started mapping out where things would go, I decided 8x8 was too big. Plus, there was the reverberation issue, which I hadn't noticed before renting the new place. I'd already ordered the horse mats cut to 2'x8'. Cutting these horse mats turned out to be not as bad as I thought. Use a new blade, go slow, firm and steady.
Before putting in the carpet and finishing with the mats and top lifting platform, I decided to move it into the final position. By this point, the platform was very heavy. Moving it was nontrivial. I was too impatient to call anyone over to help. Fortunately, I happened to spot some 1/2" diameter round metal rods in the garage which had been part of some cheap ikea shelf. I used these to easily roll the platform in position, after using a crowbar and 10 and 25 lb plates to jack the platform up. I also took the time to put a front lip or handle on the platform, which I think will make it easier to get under it to lift and move when we inevitably move from this place. I half believe in retrospect, that will turn out to be a pointless addition. I dread the thought of moving this thing to a new house in the years to come.
Once in position, I began loading up the carpet. I didn't use any carpet padding, just carpet. That seemed to be OK. I had a mix of different carpets, and I took care to make sure I put the same things in the left well as I did the right well as I loaded it up. I did load it until the carpet was above the edge, so that when I stood on it, it would compress down to around level with the top of the platform. I think this is important, so that you don't get any sag with a bar sitting on it, and hence change the starting position of the bar from what it should be. I also wonder if, down the road, I'll need to replace the carpet as it gets hammered into dust over time.
Screwing in the horse mats and top section was straightforward, though it was often tricky to find the pilot hole in the rubber after drilling it.
With the platform done, I tried it out using a new set of WFW bumpers. The starting position was good - no sag. The sound dampening was SUPERB. The ability to reduce reverberation was very good, but not perfect. Still, it made it acceptable so that I don't think I'll drive the neighbors crazy.
One thing I wonder about - should the rubber area have been wider, perhaps 2'3" on a side, rather than 2', and the center lifting platform 3'6"? Perhaps that would provide a slightly larger margin of error on a drop. I don't think I've seen a set of home-built platform plans where the center area is less than 4' wide.
That small concern aside, and aside from wishing I'd done all the cuts except plywood myself for greater precision, I'm very happy with the results.
Photos:
Frame and base done

Cross beam closeup

Carpet loading nearly complete

Completed platform





