by muddy » Wed Sep 09, 2009 2:13 am
My $0.02 is I don't get how the bar classification was done. It doesn't distinguish why the reader is buying a barbell in the first place. Just powerlifting? O-lifting?
If o-lifting, there is no way EFS - as much as i love their other gear - has a bar that is top tier. From a mechanical perspective, their bars use end screws, which are not what you want for o-lifting. Aesthetically, EFS bars are very rust prone. They also have no whip to speak of.
Ironwoody seems on the same level to me as muscle driver or rogue. Of the three, I would put ironwoody in last place, though I confess this is based on aesthetics and knurl preference rather than any hard data. The whip on the muscle driver bar is imho far superior to the ironwoody bar, but how exactly do you quantify that? They are all rated the same in terms of load.
I don't own or use the other bars listed, so I can't comment on those. But if someone is willing to spend $300USD on a new bar, rogue or muscle driver (pendlay) would be very hard to beat imho.
"One of the most basic of those rules [of the Universe] is that, with the exception of the occasional lottery winner, you pretty much get out of an effort what you put into it." -- Mark Rippetoe, "Strong Enough?"
Log Goals Program