I've been going out many times with guys from the PUA community. Some of them were regular guys trying to "improve their skills". Some of them were coaches. I've never been impressed what I saw. Actually I've been hugely disappointed.
Some of these guys have turned into good friends, but many I don't want to go out with. They're no fun and it's bad energy around you. The only thing I learned from them is to cold approach. However after a thousand approaches I still believe social circle is superior.
My experience;
* They aren't fun to go out with. They have this urge to approach women when they go out and to force things instead of just letting it happen.
* They're negative. The have this guys vs. guys thing and guys vs. women thing. I've met many very negative and frustrated guys who kept blaming women.
* They fear loss all the time. They can't talk to a woman without trying to get something out of an interaction, and even push you to do the same.
* They think masculinity is defined by the amount of women you slept with and even compete about this.
* They try to play these manipulative mind-games tricks they play on women on you as a guy too. As if you wouldn't be aware of what they're doing.
* They're too analytic. Analyzing situations all the time, thikning of the next step vs. Being in moment (it's the worrying Rara mentoined, very common)
* They have no life. It's all about meeting women.
* Etc
What I also keep hearing from them:
* The sex they get is empty
* PUA can mess you up
* They wished they never discovered this stuff
"The Game" is big part of the problem. Many guys get in the PUA community after reading that book. What they seem to miss is that Style says at the end that when he met his girlfriend, his tricks didn't work on her. And most guys want to meet 1 great girl.
###
About the Jessica Alba thing. You've seen the Paris Hilton videos? The girl is boring. And she's dumb (unless it's an act, in which case she's really smart). Is that really what you want? Or do you want it because PUAs and media tell you that's what hot?
Rion Williams recommends the same thing atypical wrote: travel & meet women abroad. If you're qualifying women on their looks alone, you're really missing on a lot.
###
I do believe there's a need for this stuff. Things are messed up.
* Guys have lived in their basement for years, playing videogames all the time.
* They have zero social skills as a result of that and never had a girlfriend.
Telling them to just go out, is like telling a fat guy to just go the gym. Yes of course it comes down to that, but some advice never hurts.
Imo guys who really have issues with this, should take care of themselves first. If you have lived in your basement for 20 year and never had a girlfriend because of that, you don't have a problem with women. You don't need push/pull and cocky & funny. You need to build your social skills and build a life.
* Take care of neediness: find yourself a purpose that is not meeting women.
* Take care of your body: do some sport, lose the fat, lose skinny look, etc. Will raise sefl-esteem.
* Take care of money: get out of debt, increase income, ... will increase quality of life.
* Build social life: best way to meet women.
* Get female friends, and listen to their dating stories. You'll learn more about that than all the theory. (But don't ask them for advice, that's counter-productive).
* Self-acceptance. Stop thinking that you're not good enough and that you have to act differently
* Authenticity. Being yourself and accept it if people don't like it. You can't expect everyone to like you.
David Deida's stuff is most likely the best thing out there.
###
Rara wrote:I know the community well. But I don't have to in order to know women.
My communication with women has been a lot smoother since I stopped worrying about to say and just started saying and doing what i was thinking. My worries about what to say and do stemmed from me trying to say and do the right things to "get her". When I realized that there was no "getting" her, just freeing her to express her desire or disinterest in me, I stopped trying to be, say, or do anything and instead started relying on my instincts. Even if it meant appearing nervous. The outsider looking in test is the worst because initiating a relationship with a girl is not about impressing an audience.
Game relies on the belief that a guy has to convince a girl to sleep with him or impress others by being cool and smooth. It doesn't work like that. She may learn things about you that make you more attractive as you get to know each other, but you cannot control her perception of you no matter how hard you try.
I can and have gone into bars in nothing but a sweatshirt and jeans and still slept with women I consider hot. I've also dressed my best and gotten not so much as a phone number. It's not what you do. It's who you are. That's based on your genes and whole life experiences, not some techniques you learn on a website. And she makes her decision based on that fact.
But I am finished with this discussion. I hope your approach finds you happiness.
This mirrors what I think. From reading your posts Playboy, it seems you believe you have to be a salesman. I wonder where that idea comes from.
You know within the first minutes, even without talking, whether you like someone or not. That works both sides. Persisting is rarely worth it.